With the right ecosystem, the base $550 Surface Laptop Go would be awesome in the classroom. For the average consumer, though, you’re going to need an upgrade or two.
I really like seeing what Microsoft is doing with the new Surface Laptop Go. Probably because it’s following the same path Google is when it comes to high-end Chromebooks by giving you a lot of value for the money. Not everyone needs a $1,000 or more laptop just like not everyone needs a $1,000 phone.
I just think I’ll like it a little more when Microsoft realizes that the ecosystem that can power a laptop like this needs to be in place, too.
Usually simple is always better.
I’m not talking as a consumer who is looking to buy a new laptop for my own use. If that was the case, I could still go with a new Surface Laptop Go (silly name, Microsoft) after I upgraded to the $700 version because you do not want any laptop that runs any flavor of Windows on a 64GB eMMC storage device. You just don’t. Windows was designed to run with more breathing room and more robust storage and you’ll wish you had it. But the $700 model, which comes with more RAM and a proper SSD, would force me to look at the competition, and there’s a good chance I’d find something else that tickles my fancy.
Where the base model $550 Surface Laptop Go really fits, though, is in the classroom. And that’s where Microsoft needs to put itself. But that’s the area Chromebooks currently dominate, and the narrative isn’t going to change anytime soon.
Microsoft has much better tools and a more robust backend for large scale deployment. But it’s not simple.
It’s crazy to say that any large organization is better served through Google’s G Suite than it is through Microsoft’s years of progress in infrastructure, but when it comes to the classroom it’s the truth. It’s not because Microsoft doesn’t have the correct tool for every task — it does. It’s not because Microsoft doesn’t offer the right software for a large group of people to work independently or in collaboration — it does. It’s because administering a group of students with Chromebooks is super easy through G Suite and the basic tools offered are perfect for working in the classroom.
Yes, I’m saying exactly what it sounds like I’m saying: Google’s “dumbed-down” version of collaborative office software combined with its simple but easy-to-administer backend for Chromebooks works better because it’s “dumbed-down” and easy. If I ran a Fortune 500 company and wanted to buy 2,500 new laptops for all my corporate drones on the fifth floor, I’d jump all over the first rep who could sell me these new Surface Laptops. (Then probably end up buying 2,500 pieces from Dell instead because I’d save a bunch of money.)
But if I were stuck in the tough position of buying a bunch of laptops for K-12 students, I’d do things differently. I’d look at the bare minimum needed for kids to do schoolwork and make sure the barebones IT staff my district has can get those computers up, running, and in the hands of students. I hate to say it, but that takes these laptops and every laptop that’s not a Chromebook out of play.
Apple and Microsoft both know the value of being in the classroom. The new Surface Laptop Go tells me Microsoft is ready to fight its way back in.
Apple is trying to get back into the classroom through the iPad. It’s sort of working, especially in high schools or specialty technical schools. Microsoft has an easier task ahead of it, and seeing something like the new Surface Laptop Go with a silly name, weak hardware, and a reasonable price tag tells me it knows what it needs to do and is going to start doing it.
Once Microsoft figures out a simple admin console where a math teacher can fix issues with a student’s laptop himself/herself instead of calling the IT department, it’s totally game on.
Until then, something like this Surface is just a decent product in need of a good home. If you’re looking for the best Windows laptop, you can probably buy the $700 version with 128GB of storage and 8GB of RAM and have something you can use for the next five years. Just don’t get sucked into buying the base model because you’ll regret it.
At a glance
The Pixelbook Go is a stupendous all-round laptop that doesn’t pretend to be anything different. It can’t fold to become a tablet, but it can last nearly 10 hours on a charge and make typing feel fun again. This is the premium Chromebook to buy right now.
From $649 at Amazon