Microsoft exec responds to Windows 11 AI controversy, but glosses over a key reason for all the hate

  • Pavan Davuluri, head of Windows at Microsoft, has responded to negative reaction about AI in Windows 11
  • The exec admitted “we know we have work to do on the experience” in terms of getting the basics of Windows 11 right
  • That includes fixes for “everyday usability, from inconsistent dialogs to power user experiences” – but the exec misses a key point in terms of the hate for ads in Windows 11

The Microsoft executive who caught a lot of flak for comments about how Windows 11 is ‘evolving into an agentic OS’ has responded to that reaction, and assured the unhappy folks out there that Microsoft isn’t just focusing on AI with the desktop OS.

Windows Central reports that Pavan Davuluri, Microsoft’s VP of Windows and Devices, has posted again on X, after disabling comments for the original post that sparked this controversy – evidently looking to put a proverbial lid on things here.

In the new post responding to a complaint from author Gergely Orosz, who questions why software developers should choose Windows “with this weird direction [Microsoft is] doubling down on” (meaning AI), Davuluri explains that he is responding to a “bunch of the comments that people have made”.

Davuluri says: “The team (and I) take in a ton of feedback … I’ve read through the comments and see focus on things like reliability, performance, ease of use and more.”

“But I want to spend a moment just on the point you are making, and I’ll boil it down, we care deeply about developers. We know we have work to do on the experience, both on the everyday usability, from inconsistent dialogs to power user experiences. When we meet as a team, we discuss these pain points and others in detail, because we want developers to choose Windows.”

Windows Central also noticed a swing and a miss from Microsoft with an advert for Copilot on X, which is pretty bad timing given this controversy around AI. Microsoft’s marketing department appears to be OK with the below promotional footage that shows Copilot making rather a hash of things.

The footage shows someone getting help from Copilot with trying to change the text size (make it bigger) in Windows 11, but this isn’t a good demo of AI at all. Why not? Firstly, because Copilot only tells the user where to click initially, then the instructions trail off – meaning the again has to ask where to click next.

The next stumble, an outright mistake in this case, is that Copilot then ushers the user through to the menu to scale everything (icons, the whole interface), not just text – the text-only control is actually a separate menu (in Settings > Accessibility > Text size, as the reader context box on the X post makes clear).

Finally, the AI advises the user to choose 150% scaling when that’s already selected (they ignore it, and just click 200%, but there’s a confused pause before that happens).

If this is resizing text “like a pro” I’d hate to see it when Copilot’s guidance strays into amateurish realms – and none of this really helps Microsoft’s insistence on its big push with AI in Windows 11.

Analysis: the elephant-sized ads in the room

Person punching through the screen of a Windows 11 laptop in rage

(Image credit: Ollyy / Shutterstock)

It is good to see Davuluri take the time to address the complaints from last week, although arguably, the exec didn’t have much choice – such was the snowballing of negative reaction and flood of media coverage that ensued.

It’s also heartening to see Davuluri acknowledge that Microsoft needs to do better in terms of everyday use and reliability of the OS, and smoothing over performance problems – which are still hanging around in Windows 11 years after its launch.

The constant stream of bugs – felt even more keenly since the big changes in Windows 11 24H2 (with its new Germanium platform, required for Arm-based Copilot+ PCs) – is certainly a big part of the problem for everyday users of Microsoft’s operating system.

As Windows Central points out, Microsoft’s constant drip-feeding of new features into Windows 11 causes trouble – and more bugs – so that ‘continuous innovation’ philosophy perhaps needs a rethink. In other words, mulling a switch to a model of rarer feature updates to give time for more thorough testing and bug squashing.

But beyond stability and reliability, what’s notably missing from Davuluri’s pledges on X is any comment on the bad feeling around Microsoft pushing folks this way and that to use its services. I’m sure you’re familiar with the various promotional slants in Windows 11, nudging you to use Edge or OneDrive, or Windows Backup, or to sign up for a Microsoft account, or even buy games. All this advert-like activity is what some folks are calling out as a lack of respect for the Windows user in the thread of the exec’s new post (that and Microsoft’s telemetry, or collecting of data on the system).

Or, as Orosz – the person Davuluri was replying to – puts it, flagging up a comment from someone else (fj), Windows 11 “should be an operating system, not an ecosystem”, and Microsoft is losing sight of who the platform is built for. I’ve said this before, and I’ll say it again: Windows 11 at times feels less about the user experience, and more about the Microsoft experience, and in a paid-for OS, this simply isn’t acceptable or excusable.

Follow TechRadar on Google News and add us as a preferred source to get our expert news, reviews, and opinion in your feeds. Make sure to click the Follow button!

And of course you can also follow TechRadar on TikTok for news, reviews, unboxings in video form, and get regular updates from us on WhatsApp too.

Read more @ TechRadar

Latest posts

Google Antigravity adds ‘Knowledge Work’ interface for non-coding work

Following last week’s big update, Google Antigravity is rolling out a “Knowledge Work” user experience.  Read more @ 9to5google

Hunter is killing Google Home, Alexa controls for its smart ceiling fans

Hunter, a major brand for ceiling fans in the US, is pulling the plug on its Google Home and Amazon Alexa bridge for controlling...

Googlebook apps built by Googlers add macOS-like status bar shortcuts, keyboard commands

Googlebooks are a bit starved of desktop-class features at launch, but one of Google’s pitches around this platform is how apps can be built...

Fitbit Sense & Versa losing 3rd-party watch faces this month, existing downloads remain

Google announced today that Fitbit Sense and Versa smartwatches will soon lose the ability to “install or update third-party apps and clocks.” Read more @...

The TCL NXTPAPER 70 Pro is back down to its lowest all-time price

The TCL Black Friday sales have started early, beginning with the unlocked TCL NXTPAPER 70 Pro. Read more @ 9to5google

Samsung Galaxy S27 series camera specs leak, and they’re disappointing

New leaks reveal the camera specs for Samsung’s upcoming Galaxy S27 series which includes three lenses across the lineup, but not the upgrades you...

Motorola accidentally confirms its ‘Razr Flex’ wide foldable is coming in 2027

Following a past teaser, Motorola has mistakenly posted an early support page that not only confirms the name of its wide foldable as the...

Deals: Z Fold 8 $300 off + FREE Galaxy Buds On, Google Fitbit Edge from $126, LG B6 OLED $1,000 off, more

The Best Buy Week 2 early Black Friday deals are now live and we are still tracking a new all-time low on the Google...

Google Gemini rolling out ‘Memory summary’ with everything it remembers about you 

Google Gemini now offers a “Memory summary” to “view, edit, and delete what Gemini Apps understands about you.” Read more @ 9to5google

Samsung bets that you’ll either buy a Galaxy S27 Pro or Ultra next year

Samsung is teeing up to kick off 2027 with an all-new lineup of flagship smartphones, and despite rising prices at your local Best Buy,...