The U.S. finally put its foot down on AI image copyright

Théâtre D'opéra Spatial, a Midjourney image that won first prize in a digital art competitionMidjourney

AI generated works of art may be eligible to win awards at state fairs, but they are not protected under American copyright law, according to new guidance issued by the U.S. Copyright Office (USCO) on Wednesday.

The report details ways in which AI-generated video, images, and text may, and may not, be copyright protected. It finds that while generative AI is a new technology, its outputs largely fall under existing copyright rules meaning that no new laws will need to be enacted to address the issue. Unfortunately for AI content creators, the protections that are available are thin.

Recommended Videos

The courts have already ruled that AI systems themselves cannot hold copyright. The Supreme Court specified in the 1989 case, Cmty. for Creative Non-Violence v. Reid (“CCNV”), that “the author [of a copyrighted work] is . . . the person [emphasis added] who translates an idea into a fixed, tangible expression entitled to copyright protection.”

Pointing to the inherent unpredictability of an AI’s output to a given query, the USCO’s guidance argues that AI prompts don’t offer the user a sufficient degree of control over the generative process to “make users of an AI system the authors of the output.” That’s regardless of how complex and expansive the prompt is.

“No matter how many times a prompt is revised and resubmitted, the final output reflects the user’s acceptance of the AI system’s interpretation, rather than authorship of the expression it contains,” the report reads. In short, “the issue is the degree of human control, rather than the predictability of the outcome.”

That denial of protection does have its limits however. For example, the 2024 Robert Zemekis film “Here,” which featured digitally de-aged Tom Hanks and Robin Wright, has been copyrighted, despite its use of generative technologies to do the de-aging. This is because the AI is wielded as a tool rather than treated like a producer. Similarly, the USCO argues that “a film that includes AI-generated special effects or background artwork is copyrightable, even if the AI effects and artwork separately are not.”

Artists are also covered, to a degree, if they’re using an AI system to further modify their existing human-made creative works. The AI-generated elements in the resulting content wouldn’t be copyrightable (since they were generated by the AI) but the overall artistic piece, and its “perceptible human expression,” would be.

This issue is not a new one. As far back as 1965 with the advent of computers, the USCO has been wrestling with the question of authorship as to whether content produced on digital platforms is the work of human authors or simply “written” by the computers.

“The crucial question appears to be whether the “work” is basically one of human authorship, with the computer merely being an assisting instrument,” Then-Register of Copyrights Abraham Kaminstein noted at the time, “or whether the traditional elements of authorship in the work (literary, artistic, or musical expression or elements of selection, arrangement, etc.) were actually conceived and executed not by man but by a machine.”

The USCO notes that its guidance on the issue could evolve in the coming years as the technology further matures. “In theory, AI systems could someday allow users to exert so much control over how their expression is reflected in an output that the system’s contribution would become rote or mechanical,” the report reads. However, the USCO has found that modern AI prompts simply do not yet rise to that level.

Editors’ Recommendations

  • Google is about to give its Gemini AI a transfusion of accurate news

  • Microsoft nixes its Dall-E upgrade after image quality complaints

  • It’s not just you: ChatGPT is currently down

  • I tried out Google’s latest AI tool that generates images in a fun, new way

  • More proof that AI images are becoming modern-day clip art




Related posts

Latest posts

This YouTuber just made the TikTok situation a lot more complicated

A well-known YouTuber has hinted at his interest in purchasing TikTok, making an already-complicated situation even murkier.

The Mac mini with Apple M2 Pro is on sale for under $1,000

Upgrade your workflow and overall productivity with the fast and reliable Apple Mac mini (M2 Pro), now on sale for only $900.

Samsung Galaxy S25 vs Galaxy S24: should you upgrade?

The Galaxy S25 is official, but should you upgrade from the Galaxy S24? Is newer better or does the one-year-old Galaxy S24 offer better value? Let's find out!

Casio’s tiny Ring Watch is completely mad and I adore it

Yes, Casio's Ring Watch is a real watch you wear on your finger, not your wrist. It's as mad as it sounds, and I've been wearing it.

Google’s “Ask for Me” will have an AI schedule your next oil change

Google released a new experimental AI agent that can set up nail salon and automotive shop appointments nearly automatically.

Samsung’s Now Bar is already getting more useful

Samsung's Now Bar adds Google Maps support, letting you track directions right from the lock screen. The feature will be available with the rollout of One UI 7.

Save 43% off this powerful Lenovo ThinkPad laptop — but hurry!

The Lenovo ThinkPad P16s is a powerful laptop for any business and it's currently enjoying a significant price cut at Lenovo for a limited time.

Microsoft says you can run DeepSeek R1 right on your laptop

Microsoft confirmed it will bring the DeepSeek R1 model to Azure cloud and GitHub in a move that it hopes will lessen its reliance on OpenAI's models.

M4 MacBook Air: Everything we know about Apple’s next laptop

The M4 MacBook Air is about to launch, so what should you expect when it hits store shelves? Here’s everything we know about what’s coming next from Apple.

These premium Bang & Olufsen headphones just scored a 40% discount at Amazon — but the clock is ticking

Amazon is currently slashing 40% off the Bang & Olufsen Beoplay HX headphones, but nearly half of the units have