I’m so disappointed with the Google Pixel 9 phones

How much choice is too much choice, and when does it become no choice at all? Whether it’s scrolling through Netflix or YouTube’s huge libraries or looking at a wardrobe bursting at the seams for something to wear, but finding nothing, it’s often simpler when there are just a couple of clear, well-curated choices from which to select.

Google has gone full “packed wardrobe” with the new Pixel 9 series. There are four different models in the range, with a fifth already on the shelf, and I’m about to tell you why Google has still gotten it all wrong.

Recommended Videos

Your choices for the Pixel 9

Ajay Kumar / Digital Trends

For 2024, you can choose between the 6.3-inch Pixel 9, the 6.3-inch Pixel 9 Pro, the 6.8-inch Pixel 9 Pro XL, and the 6.3-inch/8-inch Pixel 9 Fold Pro. The screen represents the biggest visual difference between the different phones, apart from small changes in the battery capacity. Of course, the higher up the range you go, the more technically impressive the camera gets. The 9 Pro Fold stands slightly apart, as it has two screens, and the camera sits somewhere in between all the non-folding Pixel 9 phones.

Google has four “main” phones and a foldable phone, ready to please everyone regardless of whether they want a small, medium, or large phone with a good camera or not. Or so it thinks. It has also hit those all-important price points (which is really what its newly fattened range is all about) with the Pixel 9 yours for $799, the Pixel 9 Pro for $999, the Pixel 9 Pro XL for $1,099, and the Pixel Fold Pro at the top of the pile at $1,799. Don’t forget about the Pixel 8a either, a 6.1-inch phone for $499.

This is too many examples of the same phone, with the Pixel 9 Pro and Pixel 9 Pro XL being the worst offenders, as they are the same phone split in two, with one adopting the Pixel 9’s screen size, yet keeping the best camera found on the bigger phone. Inside the marketing hive mind, this means the 9 Pro is a “small” flagship phone for those who don’t want a screen as large as the Pixel 9 Pro XL’s, but don’t want to miss out on the camera. Brilliant! A big seller, for sure, they all tell each other. Except, it’s not small at all, is it?

These are not small phones

Ajay Kumar / Digital Trends

The Pixel 9 and Pixel 9 Pro are the same physical size and, interestingly, also share basically the same dimensions as the Pixel 8a, a phone with a 6.1-inch screen. They are just 4.6mm less wide than the Pixel 9 Pro XL, but 10mm shorter. All three have the same 8.5mm depth, but the weights are different, with the 9 Pro XL being 22 grams heavier than the other Pixel 9 phones, which are just a gram or two away from being 200 grams. It’s hardly a range filled with dramatically different models, and I bet people will gravitate toward the top or bottom of the pile.

None of these are small or light smartphones and, therefore, become variations on the same theme. Sure, the Pixel 9 Pro does a good impression of being a small flagship device, as it sits neatly in the middle of the Pixel 9 and Pixel 9 Pro XL on paper, but since when has a 199-gram, 72mm-wide, 8.5mm-thick phone with a 6.3-inch screen been small? It hasn’t, and I wonder whether anyone who really wants a high-end small phone will truly be satisfied with it.

The Asus Zenfone 10 Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

Apple makes a smallish flagship smartphone. It’s the iPhone 15 Pro and it has a 6.1-inch screen, is 187 grams, and 70mm wide. Asus does it properly with the Zenfone 10, which weighs just 172 grams, is 68mm wide, and has a 5.92-inch screen. That’s a small phone by today’s standards, but even it looks big next to the old iPhone 13 Mini with its 5.4-inch screen, 64mm width, and 141 gram weight. Google hasn’t got anywhere near making a small Pixel phone. Instead, it now has three phones that are bigger and heavier than a Samsung Galaxy S24.

Who wants what?

Pixel 9 Pro XL Joe Maring / Digital Trends

None of Google’s Pixel phones are small, but it doesn’t matter as, for the most part, nobody actually buys small phones despite saying they want one. Google has really made various “Plus” phones, but most of the time, those phones are the ones no one wants either. These awkward Plus models sit in the middle of the range, pleasing nobody, as you either think the standard model will be fine or simply go all-out and buy the top one.

Google has successfully made its range confusing. I don’t want the basic model because I want the best camera, but the 9 Pro isn’t really all that smaller than the 9 Pro XL, and the bigger battery and screen are worth the extra $100, so I’ll just get that one. Or I want a really big screen and I am not so worried about the camera, so I’ll get the 9 Pro Fold. Or maybe that’s too expensive, so I’ll just get the 9 Pro XL. If I want a cheap Pixel, then the Pixel 8a is much cheaper than the Pixel 9.

Ajay Kumar / Digital Trends

The Pixel 9 range is bigger than ever before, but it does not seem to solve any more problems than before. Instead, it makes the buying decision harder as, in all likelihood, more than one phone will do what you want, or if you’re really unlucky, what you want will fit in between two models, and you won’t know which to pick.

It’s a problem of Google’s own making. If it wanted to make a small flagship phone, it should have made one, even if no one went on to buy it. What we’ve got is a collection of phones that have been made to fit a price and have ended up being much too similar, bookended by a cheap phone with older tech and a very big, very expensive phone. At least one model in the Pixel 9 range is going to be ignored anyway, and I’d rather that have been a genuinely different model from the ones we’ve got.

Editors’ Recommendations

  • The biggest mistake Google made with the Pixel 9 and Pixel Watch 3

  • The Google Pixel Watch 3 has a never-before-seen health feature

  • Everything you need to know about the Google Pixel 9

  • Gemini has killed Google Assistant to become the AI future of Android

  • Everything you need to know about the Google Pixel Watch 3




Related posts

Latest posts

Galaxy A56 leak reveals official colors of Samsung’s chief mid-ranger

Fresh leak confirms the design and official color options of the upcoming Samsung Galaxy A36 mid-ranger.

I tested the Galaxy S25 Plus and Pixel 9 Pro cameras, it’s no contest

If you’re looking for a new flagship Android phone and want something that’s pocket-friendly, you’ve probably been considering Google’s flagship, the . However, you may also be considering Samsung’s latest middle flagship, the . Both phones have very similar features, with each company equipping its flagship with a flagship processor, good battery life, and an […]

Apple has a chance to correct one of its biggest mistakes — and it could happen imminently

According to rumors, Apple is about to announce something big for the Vision Pro headset this week. Here’s why a price drop should be top of the list.

We’ve got the date for Google’s biggest event of 2025

Google will hold its annual developer conference, Google I/O, in May this year.

This tech can end QR code scams, if only Google and Apple pitch in

QR code phishing has emerged as a serious threat. A retrofit variation that uses cryptographic security and can even work offline might just be the solution.

This tech can end QR code scams, if only Google and Apple pitch in

QR code phishing has emerged as a serious threat. A retrofit variation that uses cryptographic security and can even work offline might just be the solution.

One UI 7 lets parents restrict their children from seeing adult sites and harmful apps

New measures in Samsung's One UI 7 let parents limit access to sexually explicit websites and harmful or violent apps on their children's phones.

The Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 for $200? It’s possible with this offer

Samsung's trade-in credit program for the Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 is offering up to $600 off for an eligible device, so you can pay as low as $200 for the tablet.

Affordable phone with no camera bump? This could be it

It has been a busy week for news regarding the Google Pixel 9a. More information about its design surfaced just days after the likely colors for the new budget phone leaked. In exclusive news, has released official renders of the new phone, which is expected to be announced on Wednesday, February 17 in just one […]

Is the Galaxy S25 Ultra zoom the best? I tested it and it’s close

The year was 2020, the month was February and Samsung had just kicked off yet another smartphone generation. The Galaxy S20 Ultra brought a lot of new features to the market, but crucially, Samsung’s marketing also made long zoom features and Ultra branding extremely desirable. One of the key reasons to buy the Galaxy S20 […]