12.5 C
New York
Monday, January 25, 2021
Home News When adding new Android features, Google needs to be more like Samsung

When adding new Android features, Google needs to be more like Samsung

pixel-3a-android-11-media-notification-aAndroid-figures.jpg

Why do features we see from phone makers take so long to make it into Android itself?

Google likes to tell everyone that Android is all about choice. We have hundreds of great phones that all run on Android, and you’ll probably be able to find exactly what you want when it comes to things like color or size or price. From the top phone makers, you also find a little extra. Sometimes, you find that same “extra” in every great phone except Google’s Pixels.

There’s a reason this happens. Google Pixel phones do not run bare-bones Android built using only the open-source version. Like Samsung or LG or OnePlus, it takes that code and adds a little to it. But the system itself only uses the standard set of APIs (Application Programming Interfaces) that Google has built for Android while companies like OnePlus or Samsung use those to add in some of their own for their apps to use.

pixel-5-vs-pixel-4a-5g_0.jpg

That doesn’t mean that the Pixel doesn’t have its own features — the great call screening comes to mind, as does the original expansion of Google Assistant. But these are a way around the rules by leveraging Google services and data to build something like a phone dialer that has a wealth of information in Google’s servers regarding spam calls. If another company had an equal amount of data, it could build its own version that’s just as good. That’s something Samsung is working on right now.

If you want an app to work on every phone, there needs to be a standardized set of APIS.

The reason the Android team at Google builds out a specific set of APIs is simple: these are the things app developers use to make sure an app can run on every device with access to Google Play. This is something Google really wants, and so should we. But Google doesn’t go as far as saying Samsung, for example, can’t build out its own set of APIs and services, which it and almost every other phone maker does.

I’m going to take the most recent example of a feature that most other phones — even budget phones — have that isn’t a part of Android: scrolling screenshots. Scrolling screenshots aren’t part of Android, and you have them on your phone because the company that made your phone is using some code of its own added on top of what Google provides.

oneui-screenshot-controls-blue-leather.j

It gets even weirder when you hear that the team behind the Chrome app for Android is working on adding the feature to the browser. If you’re thinking that something almost all phone makers and the team that works on Chrome for Android can do is something Google should be able to do, you’re both right and wrong.

The wrong part is that when Samsung adds the scrolling screenshot feature to something like the Note 20 or Galaxy S20 FE, it is only designed to work on that specific phone. The app doesn’t need to figure out the dimensions of the display or its aspect ratio or color bit depth. It only has to send data to the phone’s memory until you say stop, then convert that into an image.

A screenshot app on the S20 FE already knows everything about the screen and has access to capture as you scroll.

It kind of works that way through Chrome, too. Chrome has already calculated the size and shape of the window and everything it needs to copy in order to build an image file is inside that window. If and when Google adds the feature to Android itself, it has to make it able to work on every Android model and in every app. It needs a way to find out everything about the display: the size of the usable window, how to build an interface for the feature, and make sure all of it works on phones with wildly different hardware. This is why it seemed to take so long for Google to add proper multi-window to Android.

This is all well and good, and I understand that making something universal is a lot harder than making a feature work for one phone or for one app. I’m just done with that excuse.

Google is one of the world’s largest software companies and has some of the best talent the world has to offer working across the company. Google was built from day one as a company that is able to do the difficult things and has done just that over the past 20 or so years. If a handful of smart people were able to build a new kind of web search engine, and a handful of other people were able to find ways to make user data improve it (and improve the services for the users, too), and then figure out how to turn it all into a multi-billion-dollar company, then it can figure out how to put scrolling screenshots into Android.

samsung-galaxy-s20-fe-8.jpg

I’m using scrolling screenshots as an example here, but the way Google adds features to Android seems a bit schizophrenic. We see improvements in security and user privacy with every release which is great (and also something we see from almost every software company, thank goodness) but user-facing things often feel really disjointed. Especially when those things affect every phone that updates to the latest version of Android.

Google can figure out almost any problem if it wants to do it.

Notifications are a great example. Android has always had the best notification system of any operating system. That’s why Apple is learning how to “copy” the best parts of it to incorporate into iOS. But Google didn’t stop there and continued to improve notifications, which is great. What’s not so great is how it sometimes can’t make up its mind which direction to go or how notifications need to look or how they should be placed.

pixel-3a-android-11-media-notification-a

Most of us can grab any Android phone and understand changes to notifications pretty quickly. And most of us will find something there we don’t like. If enough of us don’t like it, then Google will try something else. But a new Android user is going to have a learning curve when it comes to things like notification settings or how they are organized or even why some can’t be dismissed.

I’m not suggesting that Android is now perfect when it comes to notifications, but maybe some resources can be moved around. Leave notifications as they are for a release or two and focus on something that people want. Adding a standard way of taking a rolling or expanding screenshot is a thing people want. If it wasn’t, Samsung and all the rest would not have added it. If Google could find a way to make it part of the operating system, it makes it easier on users because it’s the same on every phone and it makes it easier on phone makers because the work has been done for them.

android-11-notifications-1.jpg

Yes, I know this argument sounds a little self-entitled or pedantic, but it’s not meant to be. I have zero use for scrolling screenshots myself and I liked Android’s notifications in version 9 better than they are in version 11. I only used those things as examples and I’m sure every one of us sees Samsung or Motorola or Xiaomi doing something that we think should be on every phone. I’m just saying that maybe Google needs to focus going forwards. If that means slowing work on existing features to add in new ones or just hiring more developers is something only Google knows.

Android isn’t perfect as-is, but maybe it’s time to stop fiddling with the same things each release and work on more features. Or do both if possible!

What I know is that people want to see new things as well as seeing good changes to what’s already there. It seems like we can never get both for Android. In my opinion, Android is the most versatile operating system we’ve ever seen and its potential is still mostly untapped even 12 years after it was released. It means a lot of work — and the right work — is needed to keep it that way because Microsoft and Apple aren’t holding back on great ideas and additions.

Get More Pixel 5

Google Pixel 5



google-pixel-5-render.png

$700 at Amazon
$700 at Best Buy
$700 at B&H

  • Google Pixel 5 buyer’s guide
  • Google Pixel 5 review
  • Best Pixel 5 cases
  • Best Pixel 5 screen protectors
  • What color Pixel 5 should you buy?
  • Pixel 4a 5G review

Latest

Tronsmart’s latest Q10 wireless headphones are currently on a huge discount

Tronsmart makes some great smartphone accessories and audio devices. The company has gained more and more users as a budget alternative to the big brands over the last few years. Tronsmart’s latest offering is the Q10 wireless headphones.While we have yet to fully review these new active noise-canceling headphones, Tronsmart wants to share with our readers that the Q10 is currently deeply discounted for its big launch. (but stay tuned for more on that review in the next few weeks) Retail partner AliExpress has the Q10 headphones a whopping 53% off if you act quickly.This $52.99 cutback is good for the next two days. From January 25 thru the 27th, you can snag these over-ear headphones for more than half the price. This is a pretty great deal for headphones that pack a pretty decent spec sheet.The Tronsmart Q10 will get you Bluetooth 5.0, touch controls, active noise-cancellation, and an estimated 100 hours of playtime. The headset also has Google Voice support and USB-C charging to round out the bullet points.So, what are you waiting for? Get over to AliExpress using this link: http://bit.ly/TSQ10JANae to enjoy this limited time offer from Tronsmart.

US Mobile Buyer’s Guide (January 2021)

Most consumers are familiar with the big-name wireless carriers like Verizon and AT&T, but not nearly as many are as well-versed when it comes Mobile Virtual Network Operators (MVNOs) like Consumer Cellular or FreedomPop.These MNVO brand operators license the towers and coverage from the tier-one providers and offer their own phones, rate plans, and customer service.Let’s take a look at one in particular: US MobileAboutUS Mobile is a small MVNO that utilizes T-Mobile’s 4G LTE network and Verizon’s 4G LTE network and is known for letting customers add talk, text and data on the fly, at any time.The carrier is not shy about its usage of T-Mobile, but it does appear to hide its Verizon component a bit. We’re not sure why.What are US Mobile rate plans like?US Mobile touts is affordable packages for subscribers who need wireless coverage but want some flexibility in the talk, text and time used each month.Customers can pick and choose plans, customizing as they see fit, or choose from a selection of “Unlimited” options. Don’t want or need data? That’s fine.The Unlimited Plans are as follows:$15/mo – Unlimited talk, text, and 2.5GB data$30/mo – Unlimited talk, text, and 10GB dataThe custom plans come with hotspot capabilities and 250MB of 4G LTE international roaming.A recent change to the plans sees US Mobile offering a $40 option which includes unlimited talk, text, and data. To be clear, it’s 50GB of high speed data with heavier users potentially seeing reduced speeds after hitting the threshold. Data speeds are considered “Fast” which means up to 5Mbps for video streaming.For $5 more per month subscribers can get 10GB of mobile hotspot capabilities. For $10 more per month customers can increase data speeds to “Ludicrous” up to 250Mbps, plus the hotspot feature.Family PlansUS Mobile customers can create multi-line accounts, each of which is basically the $40 plan. Things get cheaper per line as you add them to the mix.US Mobile phone selectionUS Mobile has a small selection of phones to choose from, many of which are a few years old. Moreover, they appear to be fairly expensive, too. We definitely recommend using your existing T-Mobile or Verizon phone if possible.Where can I buy an unlocked phone?Bring your own deviceUS Mobile tends to work better for people who already have a phone that they’d like to use. Whether it’s a T-Mobile or Verizon handset, or something else, you’ll probably have luck using it with US Mobile. According to the carrier, 99% of devices will work with its service.What else should I know about US Mobile?US Mobile operates entirely online and does not have any physical retail locations in the US.For every friend you refer to US Mobile, the carrier will give you both up to $10. They save up to $10 on their first plan and you get up to $10 off your next bill.You can easily add talk, text, and/or data Top Ups to your current plan to always stay connected. They roll over to next month when you use AutoPay, automatic bill payment.A US Mobile starter SIM kit can be purchased for $3.99, letting subscribers keep their existing phone number.

Omoton C3 Cell Phone Stand review: It also works for tablets?!

The Omoton C3 Cell Phone Stand might work for both smartphones and tablets, making it a great option!

Nulaxy A5 Tablet Stand review: Surprising quality for the price!

The Nulaxy A5 Tablet Stand competes in a fierce, crowded market, but it has some cool features and a very