12.5 C
New York
Saturday, August 8, 2020
Home News TCL 10 Pro vs. Moto G Stylus: Is TCL worth the extra...

TCL 10 Pro vs. Moto G Stylus: Is TCL worth the extra $150?

Best overall

TCL 10 Pro

tcl-10-pro-render-front.png

  • $450 at Amazon
  • $450 at Best Buy
  • $450 at B&H

Pros

  • Excellent HDR display with SDR upscaling tech
  • Snappy performance
  • Great battery life
  • High-end glass and metal design

Cons

  • Considerably more expensive
  • Cameras are decent at best

The TCL 10 Pro more than justifies its higher price with better performance across the board. Its hardware is stunning, and the software is both clean and responsive. If you can spare the extra cash, this should absolutely be on your radar.

More affordable

Moto G Stylus

moto-g-stylus-cropped.png

  • $300 at Amazon
  • $300 at Best Buy
  • $300 at B&H

Pros

  • Costs significantly less
  • Moto Actions and Moto Display are great add-ons
  • Excellent battery life
  • Large, colorful display

Cons

  • Very weak camera performance
  • Sluggish software responsiveness

The Moto G Stylus makes too many compromises for its own good. The software is clean and the display is colorful, but performance lags behind, and the cameras simply don’t measure up to the competition.

Budget phones no longer need to make major compromises in factors like design, screen quality, and performance to reach their low price point. The TCL 10 Pro and Moto G Stylus are both very affordable phones with modern hardware and huge screens, along with clean builds of Android 10 — though for an extra $150, you should certainly expect a bit more from the 10 Pro. But that’s also a 150 percent price hike over the Moto G Stylus; are those improvements worth it for your needs?

Cameras always take the biggest hit

tcl-10-series-review-13.jpg

Both the Moto G Stylus and the TCL 10 Pro have attractive modern designs with tall, narrow aspect ratios and their own unique characteristics. The Moto G Stylus has a plastic body with bottom-firing speakers, a headphone jack, and a fingerprint sensor cleverly hidden in the Motorola logo around back. As the name implies, it also features a stylus, which tucks into the bottom-right corner of the phone when not in use.

The TCL 10 Pro has much nicer hardware — but that’s to be expected for an extra $150.

The 6.4-inch display has nice color reproduction, and its white balance is a considerable improvement over that of the previous generation Moto G7. There’s a hole punch notch in the upper-left corner that houses the front-facing camera; there’s a bit of light bleed around the cutout (the IPS LCD display tech is largely to blame here), but it’s easy to overlook, and the display looks good overall.

The TCL 10 Pro feels far more luxurious, with a glass and metal design featuring a matte, frosted backing that looks terrific and hides most fingerprints. Of course, there’s no stylus on the 10 Pro, but it’s otherwise pretty similar with a headphone jack, bottom-firing speakers, and a USB-C charging port. There’s no capacitive fingerprint sensor on the back; instead, you’ll find an in-display sensor here. It isn’t the most consistent we’ve tested, but it works fairly well considering the price.

Rather than a hole punch cutout, TCL opted for a more traditional notch stemming from the center of the display up top. That display is a slightly larger AMOLED panel, which means deeper blacks and more vivid colors. It’s powered by TCL’s NXTVISION display tech — the same technology found on the company’s TVs — which touts SDR-to-HDR conversion, among other things.

Operating System Android 10 Android 10
Display 6.47 inches, 19.5:9 aspect ratio, 2340×1080 (398 ppi) resolution, AMOLED 6.4 inches, 19:9 aspect ratio, 2300×1080 (399 ppi) resolution, IPS LCD
Processor Snapdragon 675 Snapdragon 665
Graphics Adreno 612 Adreno 610
Memory 6GB 4GB
Storage 128GB 128GB
Expandable Storage Yes Yes
Rear Camera 64MP, ƒ/1.79 (primary) 5MP, ƒ/2.2 (macro) 16MP, ƒ/2.4 (ultra-wide) 2MP, ƒ/1.8 (super low light) 48MP, ƒ/1.7 (primary) 2MP, ƒ/2.2 (macro) 16MP, ƒ/2.2 (ultra-wide)
Front Camera 24MP, ƒ/2.0 16MP, ƒ/2.0
Security In-display fingerprint sensor Rear fingerprint sensor
Battery 4500mAh 4000mAh
Water Resistance IP52 Water repellant
Dimensions 158.5 x 72.4 x 9.2 mm 158.55 x 75.8 x 9.2mm
Weight 177g 192g

moto-g-stylus-2020-hands-on-1.jpeg

Without a doubt, the Moto G Stylus’s main advantage from a hardware standpoint is its namesake stylus — though as Daniel Bader mentioned in our full review, there’s no advanced pressure sensitivity or wireless tech behind that stylus like you’d find on Samsung’s Galaxy Note lineup. Using a stylus does offer better precision than you’d get with your finger, but this particular stylus is laggy and imprecise to the point of hardly being a real benefit.

Unfortunately for Motorola, that disparity in hardware continues over to software performance. While the Moto G line once set a standard for the level of performance we could expect from budget devices, the G Stylus simply lags behind the competition. It’s sluggish and unresponsive at nearly every turn; meanwhile, the TCL 10 Pro is just as snappy as many of the recent flagships we’ve tested.

It’s sort of baffling that you can’t use the Moto G Stylus’s ultra-wide camera to take photos.

The good news is that both phones have excellent, cleanly laid out software. The 10 Pro’s TCL UI puts a large focus on display enhancements, with the aforementioned NXTVISION HDR technology and various color profiles. There’s also a customizable side key that can launch various apps and tasks. The Moto G Stylus doesn’t hone in so much on its display, but its Moto Actions software gives users quick access to features like the camera and flashlight by use of physical gestures. Moto Display is also one of our favorite implementations of the popular always-on display tech.

You probably know by now that any time you’re looking to cut costs on a phone, one of the first things to suffer is the camera experience. Neither phone takes particularly great photos, but as you might expect, the TCL 10 Pro takes the win here as well. Both phones feature high-resolution primary sensors that use pixel binning to combine information from neighboring pixels together; in both cases, this means passable photos with decent dynamic range and sharpness.

The secondary cameras are where the Moto G Stylus starts to fall apart. You get a macro sensor on each phone, but at just 2MP versus the TCL 10 Pro’s 5MP, the Moto G Stylus’s close-up shots turn out universally soft. There’s also an ultra-wide lens on both phones; quite frankly, the 10 Pro’s ultra-wide shots are bad, but at least you can use the lens to take photos. On the Moto G Stylus, that ultra-wide can only be used for its Action Cam videos, in which you can shoot horizontal footage while holding the phone vertically. It’s a neat feature with decent quality video, but the lack of any photo capabilities is an odd oversight.

In case it isn’t clear, the TCL 10 Pro offers a better experience in nearly every way. Of course, it’s also 1.5x the cost of the Moto G Stylus, but I’d argue that if you can make it work, it’s well worth the extra money. The Moto G Stylus just doesn’t offer the level of software or camera performance that we’ve come to expect these days. If you’re strapped for cash and need to stick with a ~$300 budget, though, there are plenty of other great options to consider.

Best overall

TCL 10 Pro

tcl-10-pro-render-front.png

Well worth the money if you can swing it

  • $450 at Amazon
  • $450 at Best Buy
  • $450 at B&H

The TCL 10 Pro more than justifies its higher price with better performance across the board. Its hardware is stunning, and the software is both clean and responsive.

More affordable

Moto G Stylus

moto-g-stylus-cropped.png

A hard sell, even at its low price

  • $300 at Amazon
  • $300 at Best Buy
  • $300 at B&H

The Moto G Stylus makes too many compromises for its own good. The software is clean and the display is colorful, but performance lags behind, and the cameras simply don’t measure up.

Latest

The best tutoring apps and websites

Stuck on a math problem? Need help with test prep? These five tutoring services can get you back on track.

Google Pixel 4a vs. OnePlus Nord: Which is the bigger bargain?

The Google Pixel 4a and OnePlus Nord are two of the best budget smartphones ever released, but which is best?

Here are some must-have apps for your high schooler

Summer is almost over and it's time to gear up for school. Whether your high school student is learning in

How malware started a Bitcoin hack that YouTube just can’t keep up with

We caught up with three creators who's channels were crippled during a recent YouTube hack.If you've been keeping up with