The Iowa Caucus proves that sometimes tech goes really bad

iowa_caucus-ballots.jpeg?itok=WACnAvcP

FUBAR.

A lot of people think technology is the answer to everything. They may be right, but only if the tech itself is ready. At the Iowa Caucus on Monday night, we saw what a disaster looks like when the tech isn’t ready.

I’m not going to get into politics and don’t care about the caucus vs. primary debate, or which candidate is best or anything of the sort. I’m only here to marvel at the utter failure and try to explore it. After all, it was the real star of the horror show.

What we know

iowa_shadow_app_1.jpg?itok=mefPDwHh

For starters, no votes were changed and every vote will be counted so everyone can stop talking about election interference.

No matter what candidates are saying, nobody won anything in Iowa.

What did happen was an untested app was distributed in a horrible way to untrained officials that was supposed to let them transmit results into a central server so everything could be tallied. Paper ballots are still there and the app wasn’t used by the public for voting purposes.

We also know that a big part of the problem was the backend service that was there to support the app. It was never stress-tested and busted. Officials would try to send in their results and only received an error message. Telephone support was either bogged down or non-existent and the whole mess was the work of a company called Shadow, Inc.

Importantly, this issue did not affect the underlying caucus results data. We worked as quickly as possible overnight to resolve this issue, and the IDP has worked diligently to verify results.

— Shadow, Inc. (@ShadowIncHQ) February 4, 2020

The election process worked as it should — you filled out a little piece of paper, slipped it into a box, and someone counted everything. After that, everything went south. But this is all just the result; the distribution of the app to people who received no training was equally horrible.

TestFairy

test-fairy.jpg?itok=u22LpgBZ

Thanks to some sleuthing by Motherboard and the Washington Post, we know a little bit about how the app was distributed to officials.

What a nightmare. https://t.co/xBYyfvmDo6 pic.twitter.com/KlyUuyaRb8

— Kevin Roose (@kevinroose) February 4, 2020

TestFairy is a platform used to test apps outside of Google Play or the App Store. There are several platforms that work this way, and in itself, this isn’t that strange; it gives developers a false sense of privacy and security. Motherboard quickly proved that it really does neither.

You need the training to be any sort of election official. The same goes for using buggy apps.

I’ll ignore the ageism from the Post but point out that caucus chairs received zero training about how to install an app through TesyFairy, let alone what to do when the app screwed up. Motherboard couldn’t even get the app to boot on one of the Android phones it tried. Grandma or not, you need a little bit of information to handle a bug disguised as an application.

Shadow, Inc. wasn’t ready for prime time when it came time to tally the votes, but that’s not its biggest mistake. As ZDNet points out, there was no need to reinvent the wheel, as Amazon already has an elections as a service platform it built for Obama, and Salesforce has done this a time or two.

Shadow, Inc. probably didn’t need to be hired at all, as it looks like any IT professional with an adequate staff could use the existing tools to successfully do what it wasn’t able to pull off.

What did we all learn?

The electoral process in the United States is due for an overhaul, and tech can play a big part in it all. Shadow, Inc. may have failed in Iowa, but the principle that it’s 2020 and we are connected enough that slips of paper read aloud over a telephone call is archaic. Heck, even the DMV is partially automated and we all know how slowly anything to do with the DMV moves.

Tech can help, but it needs to move slowly and methodically when used in the electoral process.

But there isn’t a need to go too far, too fast. Shadow, Inc. might well be staffed by very competent engineers who rushed out a faulty product, but it didn’t need to find a better way when there are already services and methods to do what it was contracted to do.

Maybe the time to experiment with something different is at the local level, where ballots are measured in the thousands rather than the millions, and a tech company can be present to make sure it’s awesome new way of doing something we’ve been doing since the days of ancient Rome actually works.

Until then, make sure you vote so your voice is heard and get ready for another presidential election in the U.S.

Alexa, order me some popcorn.

Let’s get cooking

AmazonBasics Microwave

amazonbasics-microwave-with-alexa-render

A small, low-power, smart microwave.

The AmazonBasics Microwave is, well, a microwave. It’s compact, has a max power of 700W, and doesn’t look half-bad. Alexa integration is fun and sometimes convenient, but not always the most useful. However, with a price of similar, non-smart microwaves, you might as well get this over anything else.

$60 at Amazon

Related posts

Latest posts

Google gives memory superpowers to Gemini for more natural chats

You will no longer have to look up past chats with Google’s chatbot. Thanks to the memory feature, it can now recall details from previous conversations.

Android 16’s latest beta promises deeper mobile photography controls

With Android 16 Beta 2, Google is upgrading the camera app framework with a hybrid exposure system, and granular controls for color temperature and tint levels.

Why are really old iPhones suddenly so popular?

In a trend driven by K-pop stars and celebrities in South Korea, old iPhone models and digital cameras have become a desirable accessory.

Apple is working on a mini-LED Studio Display, but the iMac Pro is nowhere to be found

Apple’s Studio Display could soon get a mini-LED upgrade to elevate it for professional users. Yet it’s also made me wonder if the iMac Pro is ever coming back.

Dell slashed the price of the Alienware m18 R2 gaming laptop with RTX 4080 by $420

The Alienware m18 R2 gaming laptop with the Nvidia GeForce RTX 4080 graphics card and 32GB of RAM is available from Dell for $2,380 following a $420 discount.

Possible iPhone 17 Air design looks strangely familiar

A fantastic concept video for the iPhone 17 Air has been released. It looks impressive yet somewhat familiar.

Like T-Mobile? You can pay your phone bill by playing games

T-Mobile customers can now work toward paying their monthly bill by playing mobile games in the Ad It Up app.

Galaxy S24 owners could fall a whole Android version behind the Pixel

If you own a Samsung device but not the new Galaxy S25, we have unfortunate news for you.

The competition between AMD and Nvidia is finally heating up

Nvidia has just announced the release date for its next GPU, and AMD is ready to compete.

Meta’s next big bet might be AI humanoid robots for at-home chores

Meta is reportedly moving forward with AI-powered humanoid robots. They will be developed by the same division that is behind its AI and wearable efforts.